Cookware beta · All-Clad
Owners keep the D3 as their everyday stainless pan for frying, curries and pasta, and expect it to last for decades. Many wait for a factory sale or clearance to buy.
Owners rate its durability clearly. One cooks with a full set bought secondhand that the previous owner had used heavily for years. Another moved to D3 after other pans let them down on build quality.
Price is a clear complaint. Owners call it expensive even when they are happy with it, and several only bought pieces at a factory sale, on clearance or secondhand.
Pick up to three. You get a page with just those, side by side, on the subjects owners raised.
Once it is in the kitchen, the D3 tends to become the pan people reach for every day. One owner uses a 6 quart sauté pan for nearly all their frying and for every curry and pasta dish. Another got a set as a gift, threw out their worn non-stick pans and is glad they did. A long-time cast iron cook says even a skillet they have kept for decades does not cook as well as their D3. A new owner of a 12 inch skillet joked that buying more pieces seemed likely.
The handles take some getting used to. One owner disliked the standard D3 handles and switched to the D3 Everyday line, which has flatter handles, flared rims on the saucepans, and steeper walls with more cooking surface on the skillets. Another owner has the older handles and says they have never bothered them. A few owners bring up weight, more often as a drawback than a plus, and a few mention heat control, mostly with approval. On thickness, owners are curious how the base compares across production eras, and one points out that current D3 is thinner than some rival pans that measure 3mm.
The stainless construction keeps working. One owner has used an older set for about four years. It is old enough that it is not even marked D3, and the family it came from had cooked with it constantly. A sauté pan bought at a factory sale is still in daily use, and an owner who replaced another brand's pans for quality reasons switched to D3 because it holds up better.
These accounts do not describe anything breaking, and they say nothing about repairs, warranty claims or how owners deal with wear. The long-term evidence is thin: one owner gives a time frame of a few years, and the rest say it holds up without saying for how long. Treat the durability praise as encouraging but based on few accounts.
Nothing has a clear majority against it yet. Counted from the owners who raised each subject, not from everyone. A subject is judged once at least 4 owners raise it.
3 more subjects came up from fewer than 4 owners each, which is not enough for a fair reading. To see how it stacks up, compare it with another machine.
The same owner, asked again at each point. Fills in as owners answer.
Two questions: how long you have had it, and anything you would like to say about it. Then we ask again as it ages. This helps our mission.
More in cookware: Le Creuset Dutch Oven, Lodge Dutch Oven.
Among the 1 owner accounts here that gave a duration, 0 described a failure.
Before you buy one used, ask the seller: how old it is, whether it was ever repaired and by whom, and whether any of the parts above have been replaced. Ask to see it run. A receipt tells you the warranty start date; most makers honour the term only for the first owner.
Public discussions we read and summarised in our own words. Nothing here was submitted to Still Kicks.
Counted from public accounts by people who said they own it, and summarised by Still Kicks in its own words. Not a manufacturer claim, a lab test or an estimate.
No account needed to look. Sign in with Google only if you want to track something you own.