Cookware beta · Lodge
A heavy enameled pot that owners keep for decades and reach for most days: braising, soups, and weekly sourdough, at a price they weigh against costlier French brands.
It lasts. One owner has cooked with the same set for close to three decades, another has used the Dutch oven almost daily for more than ten years, and nobody in the durability accounts reported one wearing out.
Owners are divided on price. Some see it as the sensible buy against Le Creuset and Staub, which cost several times more without being several times better; others point out that a far cheaper Ikea enameled Dutch oven bakes sourdough just as well, and one regrets spending big on a bundled cookware set.
Pick up to three. You get a page with just those, side by side, on the subjects owners raised.
What keeps delighting people is how much of their cooking ends up in this one pot. Owners list soups, sauces, vegetables, braised meats, pasta, rice, eggs, and bread, and one said that if they had to rebuild their kitchen from nothing, this would be the first thing bought. Sourdough is the standout: several bake in it a couple of times a week, and one owner's best beef ever came out of it as a braise for tacos.
The routine side is the enamel. Owners who also have bare cast iron Dutch ovens say the enameled one gets used most because it skips the seasoning upkeep, which matters more in a deep pot than a skillet. Adjustments are small but real: a light interior stains easily (though it also makes any chip obvious), bread bakers trade notes on whether to preheat it empty or start it in a cold oven, and the weight is something people accept as the middle ground between bare cast iron and stainless. Size is a personal call: one owner found the small one too small and the largest too big, while another says a three-quart is perfect for two people in an apartment.
The body of the pot holds up for a very long time. Accounts run from over a decade of near-daily use to a set approaching thirty years, and one owner still has a century-old Dutch oven from an older maker, though its uncoated interior eventually rusted. The failure owners mention is the enamel: one cooking surface chipped within a few months, and that owner filed a warranty claim, got a replacement, and reports no problems nearly two years on. A couple of owners also say the Lodge enamel is adequate rather than exceptional next to Staub or Le Creuset.
The long-term record here is thin. A handful of owners have genuinely lived with one for ten years or more, and they are uniformly happy, but most of the accounts behind this page are about how the pot cooks, not how it ages. One early chip and one warranty replacement are not enough to say how often the enamel gives out. Treat the durability praise as encouraging and the enamel as the part to watch.
Nothing has a clear majority against it yet. Counted from the owners who raised each subject, not from everyone. A subject is judged once at least 4 owners raise it.
5 more subjects came up from fewer than 4 owners each, which is not enough for a fair reading. To see how it stacks up, compare it with another machine.
The same owner, asked again at each point. Fills in as owners answer.
Two questions: how long you have had it, and anything you would like to say about it. Then we ask again as it ages. This helps our mission.
More in cookware: Le Creuset Dutch Oven, All-Clad D3.
Among the 1 owner accounts here that gave a duration, 0 described a failure.
Before you buy one used, ask the seller: how old it is, whether it was ever repaired and by whom, and whether any of the parts above have been replaced. Ask to see it run. A receipt tells you the warranty start date; most makers honour the term only for the first owner.
Public discussions we read and summarised in our own words. Nothing here was submitted to Still Kicks.
Counted from public accounts by people who said they own it, and summarised by Still Kicks in its own words. Not a manufacturer claim, a lab test or an estimate.
No account needed to look. Sign in with Google only if you want to track something you own.